Nietzsche's contribution to this question is a plea against every sort of historical optimism; but he energetically repudiates the ordinary pessimism, which is the result of degenerate or enfeebled instincts--of decadence. He preaches with youthful enthusiasm the triumph of a tragic culture, introduced by an intrepid rising generation, in which the spirit of ancient Greece might be born again. He rejects the pessimism of Schopenhauer, for he already abhors all renunciation; but he seeks a pessimism of healthiness, one derived from strength, from exuberant power, and he believes he has found it in the Greeks. He has developed this view in the learned and profound work of his youth, The Birth of Tragedy, or Hellenism and Pessimism, in which he introduced two new terms, Apollonian and Dionysian. The two Greek deities of art, Apollo and Dionysus, denote the antithesis between plastic art and music. The former corresponds to dreaming, the latter to drunkenness. In dreams the forms of the gods first appeared to men; dreams are the world of beauteous appearance. If, on the other hand, we look down into man's lowest depths, below the spheres of thought and imagination, we come upon a world of terror and rapture, the realm of Dionysus. Above reign beauty, measure and proportion; but underneath the profusion of Nature surges freely in pleasure and pain. Regarded from Nietzsche's later standpoint, the deeper motive of this searching absorption in Hellenic antiquity becomes apparent. Even at this early stage he suspects, in what passes for morality, a disparaging principle directed against Nature; he looks for its essential antithesis, and finds it in the purely artistic principle, farthest removed from Christianity, which he calls Dionysian.
krytyka · An Essay on Aristocratic Radicalism
Pesymizm siły i dionizyjskość
Georg Brandes, Aristocratic Radicalism (1889)interpretacja
Brandes twierdzi, że Nietzsche odrzucił zarówno optymizm historyczny, jak i wyrzekający się pesymizm Schopenhauera, szukając u Greków pesymizmu siły i bujnej mocy; odczytywana z jego późniejszego stanowiska dionizyjskość była już jego przeciwzasadą wobec moralności wrogiej naturze i wobec chrześcijaństwa.
Tekst oryginalny (angielski)
- Potwierdzenie („tak” wobec życia, amor fati)Wywodzi potwierdzenie z wczesnego ideału zdrowego, tragicznego pesymizmu, płynącego z siły, a nie z wyrzeczenia.
- Chrześcijaństwo, kapłani i potrzeba czciDionizyjskość pomyślana zostaje jako zasada artystyczna najdalsza od antynaturalnej moralności chrześcijaństwa.